Former FBI Director has been called many things by critics and fans alike. However, it appears that his stab at being a pop singer did not pan out. Comey recently raised eyebrows with an account of his singing Beyoncé’s “Sandcastles” to FBI officials in a classified briefing ⦠only to be met by a stony silence.
It appears that some of his agents may have viewed the occasion as grounds for intervention rather than for rendition. In fairness to the agents, they were likely unaware of Comeys use of beaches to uncover hidden intelligence and messages.
Comey has periodically popped up in the press with bizarre or self-edifying posts. However, this one left many scratching their heads. Yet, it was vintage Comey, including a surprising admission about his handling of classified information.
Comey recalled the moment from a when he realized that a secret program being discussed was named after a favorite song. He wrote:
“One morning, I was sitting at the head of a big table in a crowded room to get briefed on a particular piece of work. The briefer started by saying, the operation was codenamed Sandcastles. Now, this was 2016, and you may know that Beyoncés album Lemonade had come out with a track called Sandcastles. So, I said, Oh, like the Beyoncé song. Blank stares all around the FBI conference room. So, I did the natural thing. I think I sang, We rebuild sand castles that washed away. Nope, nothing â dead silence. Never mind, I said, “continue. Only when I got home and told my family the story did I get the reaction I was looking for. When I write, I listen to classical or jazz because, in ways I cant explain, the music unlocks something. It frees me.”
It also apparently freed Comey from security protocols. His charming story included the fact that, disappointed by his audience at the FBI, he decided to repeat it to his family. In doing so, he may have revealed the code name of a classified FBI program to uncleared individuals in an unsecured location. This is no indication from Comey whether the code name was considered sensitive information by the FBI before his encore performance.
The has fought in court to withhold code names as sensitive national security matters, including during Comeys tenure as director.
For example, in N.Y. Times v. DOJ, 2023, it was uncontested that the FBI could withhold code names because “specific code names that [the] FBI used for certain FBI programs and that disclosure of these things would risk circumvention of the law by revealing FBI processes and potential issues related to relationships with foreign countries.”
This is not the first time Comey has raised concerns of his violation of FBI protocols and procedures regarding classified material. The Justice Department inspector general issued a scathing account of how, after being fired by President , Comey improperly removed FBI files and then arranged for the information to be leaked to the media to undermine Trump.
The media immediately came to his defense despite his having led investigations into leakers in the past. On CNN and MSNBC, legal experts dismissed the arguments that this was improper or FBI material.
The memos clearly reveal that Comey was likely aware they contained possible classified information. Comey wrote in a Jan. 7, 2017, memo that “I am  not sure of the proper classification, so I have chosen secret.” The four memos, including two given to his friend to leak to the media, were later found to be classified.
What was notable about the leaks was Comeys obsession with his own public persona. He took FBI material to bolster his image with the media. He later publish
